The Route Score
How I score
What each score feels like, anchored to bottles I've actually poured.
The four signs
- 8-10Pull Over
Worth stopping the car for. Buy it when you see it.
0 bottles so far - 7On Your Way
Good bottle. Grab it if the stop is already on your route.
1 bottle so far - 5-6
Fine pour, but there is something better one exit up.
2 bottles so far - 0-4Keep Driving
Not worth the stop.
0 bottles so far
A half point stays in the band of the whole number below it. 10s are rare. A 6.8 is still Next Exit and a 7.8 is still On Your Way.
The scale, in bottles

The ceiling. If it doesn't stand next to these, it isn't a 10.
George T. Stagg (136.1) and William Larue Weller (133.6).

Great ryes.
Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Special Release Tanyard Hill Rye 2025 (141.6) and Michter's US*1 Barrel Strength Toasted Barrel Finish Rye (108).


Great. Take a trip to get it.
Stagg batch 26C (124.6) and Russell's Reserve 13 Year barrel proof.

Solid pours.
Colonel E.H. Taylor Single Barrel, Bottled in Bond (100).
My reviews in this range

Weller Special Reserve (90).

